Monica Kelsey: From Troublemaker to Advocate

Family is where our stories begin, and for Monica Kelsey, founder of Safe Haven Baby Boxes, that story is uniquely powerful. In a special episode of Beyond the Box, Monica invites her younger sister Mindy to interview her, creating a candid conversation that weaves together childhood memories, family dynamics, and the deeply personal journey that led to Monica's life-changing work.

The sisters begin by reflecting on their childhood roles – Monica as "the instigator," her older sister Gina as "the good girl," and Mindy as "the informer." Through laughter and gentle ribbing, they share stories that paint a picture of Monica's rebellious youth, from sneaking out windows to meet boyfriends to hosting unauthorized house parties. These memories, while humorous, reveal the foundations of Monica's determined spirit and her willingness to challenge boundaries – qualities that would later serve her advocacy work.

A particularly poignant aspect of their conversation centers on adoption. Monica and her older sister were both adopted, while Mindy was their parents' biological child. The sisters discuss how their parents created an environment where adoption was simply part of their normal family narrative – never hidden, never treated as something that made Monica or Gina any less a part of the family. As Mindy recalls, "Mom always had that scar on her belly from all the C-sections... I remember asking her, 'Did Gina and Monty come out of your belly?' And she said, 'Nope, they came out of my heart.'" This beautiful explanation encapsulates the loving foundation that shaped Monica's understanding of adoption from an early age.

The conversation takes a more serious turn as Monica shares her experience meeting her biological mother later in life. Unlike her sister Gina who had no interest in exploring her biological roots, Monica was driven by curiosity to learn her story. This meeting proved transformative, confirming her gratitude for her adoptive family while also giving her insight into the challenges her birth mother faced. This dual perspective now fuels Monica's advocacy, allowing her to approach her work with both empathy for birth mothers and appreciation for adoptive families.

Perhaps most revealing is how Monica's personal experience shapes her current mission. When faced with criticism from anti-adoption voices on social media, Monica stands firm in her conviction that adoption can be a beautiful option that prioritizes a child's wellbeing. Drawing from her professional experiences and her sister's work in child welfare, they discuss the harsh realities many children face when left in dangerous situations. Monica powerfully articulates that before children deserve to know their heritage, they deserve the right to life itself – a foundational principle behind her work with Safe Haven Baby Boxes.

Throughout the conversation, the sisters' easy rapport and shared memories create an intimate backdrop for exploring how personal history shapes public mission. Their discussion illuminates how Monica's understanding of being both wanted and chosen by her adoptive parents, coupled with her compassion for her biological mother's circumstances, created the perfect foundation for her life's work – ensuring every child has the chance to be safe, wanted, and loved.

As the episode concludes with a humorous retelling of a teenage house party gone wrong, listeners are left with a comprehensive understanding of how Monica's journey – from rebellious teen to Navy veteran to advocate – represents a life where personal experience transforms into purposeful action. Her story reminds us that our beginnings, however complex, need not define our futures but can instead inspire us to create meaningful change in the world.

Listen or Watch now!

Want to Help Write the Next Story?

You can help change the ending for the next baby in crisis. Whether it’s supporting a new Baby Box, sharing the Safe Haven hotline, or giving monthly, your involvement with Safe Haven Baby Boxes changes lives. 

Because every life deserves a chance.
Because every child deserves a story of hope.

Support Safe Haven Baby Boxes
🎧 Listen now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts!

Thank you for being a vital part of our Safe Haven family. Your passion and support make all the difference.