The Journey of Safe Haven Baby Boxes: A Story of Redemption and Purpose

The inspiring journey of Safe Haven Baby Boxes began with two women on a trip to Cape Town, South Africa. Monica Kelsey, founder of Safe Haven Baby Boxes, and her friend Pam Stenzel witnessed something revolutionary – a "Baby Safe" built into the wall of a church. This simple device allowed mothers in crisis to safely and anonymously surrender their newborns rather than abandoning them in unsafe conditions. That moment of discovery sparked what would become a life-saving movement spanning 22 states across America.

What began as a basic sketch on a Delta Airlines napkin has transformed into an organization that has saved countless newborn lives. The concept was simple but revolutionary: create a safe, anonymous option for mothers in crisis who cannot or will not use traditional face-to-face surrender options. While Safe Haven laws have existed for decades, they required mothers to physically hand their babies to first responders or hospital staff – an intimidating prospect for women in desperate situations who fear judgment, shame, or legal consequences. By providing a truly anonymous alternative, Safe Haven Baby Boxes addressed a critical gap in infant abandonment prevention.

The journey hasn't been without significant opposition. Critics, particularly from adoption rights groups, have consistently argued that children deserve to know their biological parents and medical history. As Monica points out in the podcast, "They deserve to know their medical history should trump everything else, and I don't agree with that. I think your right to life trumps everything else." This fundamental value – that saving a life takes precedence over all other considerations – forms the cornerstone of the organization's philosophy of "baby first, mom second."

Both Monica and Pam bring personal perspectives to this work as adoptees themselves. Pam shares her powerful story of being born to a 15-year-old rape victim who was in foster care. Despite being "the poster child for abortion" in the 1960s, her birth mother chose life and adoption. Pam's gratitude for this decision shapes her advocacy: "She took on all the pain in order to give me my life and my family, and I will forever be grateful." These personal experiences inform their compassionate approach to mothers in crisis, recognizing that women need support regardless of which option they choose – parenting, adoption, or safe surrender.

The podcast highlights a crucial distinction between confidentiality and anonymity. While traditional Safe Haven surrenders are confidential, they are not truly anonymous, as the mother must face first responders. For many women in crisis, particularly in small communities where they might know the firefighters or hospital staff, this face-to-face interaction creates an insurmountable barrier. The baby boxes provide true anonymity, allowing mothers to prioritize their baby's safety without sacrificing their privacy. As Monica explains, "Confidentiality and anonymity [are] two different things... the only way to do that is through a safety device, which is a baby box."

Perhaps most inspiring is how this movement continues to expand despite persistent challenges. From skepticism that the boxes would "make it too easy" to surrender (ignoring the difficult decision-making process mothers go through) to regulatory hurdles in many states, Safe Haven Baby Boxes faces constant battles. Yet the organization remains focused on its mission, changing public perception through education and awareness. When a baby is safely surrendered, they publicize the positive outcome to reassure mothers and inform the community, counterbalancing the negative stories of unsafe abandonments that dominate headlines.

Listen or Watch now!

Want to Help Write the Next Story?

You can help change the ending for the next baby in crisis. Whether it’s supporting a new Baby Box, sharing the Safe Haven hotline, or giving monthly, your involvement with Safe Haven Baby Boxes changes lives. 

Because every life deserves a chance.
Because every child deserves a story of hope.

Support Safe Haven Baby Boxes
🎧 Listen now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts!

Thank you for being a vital part of our Safe Haven family. Your passion and support make all the difference.